Custom Swaps & Collars
Bilaterally negotiated OTC instruments for institutions that carry real player-performance risk: clubs, agencies, insurers, funds. Symmetric exposure, ISDA documentation, Eligible Contract Participants only.
The problem these solve
A club guarantees a star $51M a year for fifteen years. The club's true exposure is the gap between salary paid and on-field value received — and today the only hedge on offer is disability insurance, which pays on a single trigger: a medically adjudicated injury. Claims are contested, settlements take months, premiums on long guarantees are steep, and carriers routinely exclude pre-existing conditions or decline the risk outright.
More importantly, most of the ways a guaranteed contract goes bad are not medical events, and insurance covers none of them:
- Suspension — PED, gambling, off-field conduct
- Mental health and personal leave
- Pure underperformance — the skills decline and nobody gets hurt
- An early aging cliff, role loss, load management, nagging sub-clinical injuries
- The quiet middle: healthy, playing every day, producing half the projection
A WAR swap doesn't ask why. It settles on published output — cause-agnostic, no adjudication, no claims process. Every scenario above shows up in realized WAR, so every scenario above is covered. That is why these instruments complement insurance rather than compete with it.
Hedge: the out-of-the-money WAR put
The core club structure. The club buys a floor struck below projection and is paid dollar-for-dollar (per index point, at the negotiated notional rate) if the player's season lands beneath it — whatever the cause:
Projection 6.5 · floor 3.0 · $1.5M per point:
April injury (0.5) → club receives $3.75M
Suspension year (1.5) → club receives $2.25M
Quiet decline (2.0) → club receives $1.5M
Solid season (5.0) → expires; cost is the premiumThe injury row is the only one insurance could have touched — and the put pays all four identically, with no adjudication of cause. Pricing is empirical: the premium comes from the historical distribution of outcomes for comparable player profiles, plus the writer's margin.
Align: the WAR call
The upside instrument is not a hedge — it's an alignment tool for the club-player relationship. A club negotiating an extension with performance escalators can buy a call struck where the escalators begin, so the bonus liability arrives pre-funded:
Escalators keyed to index ≥ 6.0 · $1M per point:
Player posts 8.0 → club owes +$2M bonus · call pays +$2M
Player posts 6.5 → club owes +$0.5M · call pays +$0.5M
Player posts 4.0 → no bonus owed · call expiresWhy clubs want it: they can offer richer pay-for-output terms without balance-sheet risk — star seasons cost nothing net of the call. Why players and agents want it: bigger, transparent upside keyed to a published, versioned index instead of negotiated incentive language and its edge cases.
Combining them: the zero-cost collar
Buy the put, sell the call, and the premiums net to zero. Between the strikes nothing changes hands; only the tails transfer:
Floor 3.0 / Cap 7.0 at $1.5M per point:
Index < 3.0 → club receives (3.0 − Index) × $1.5M
3.0 – 7.0 → no exchange
Index > 7.0 → club pays (Index − 7.0) × $1.5MA season-ending April injury (index 0.5) pays the club $3.75M. A vintage MVP year (index 9.0) costs $3.0M — happily paid, since the on-field surplus dwarfs it. This is the symmetric, true-hedging profile institutions require, versus the all-or-nothing retail binary.
Full exposure transfer: fixed-for-floating
For counterparties that want the whole distribution rather than the tails, the classic swap: pay a fixed leg set off projection, receive the floating realized index at the notional rate — Net = (Actual − 5.0) × $1M. Pay-fixed monetizes surplus production; receive-fixed insures a sunk salary. Same paper, reversed roles.
Who hedges
- Clubs — floor the back half of long guaranteed contracts, where actuarial decline risk concentrates.
- Agents & players — lock in today's projection ahead of free agency (long-own-performance direction only; integrity guardrails below).
- Insurers — write index-triggered floors that map to existing career-ending-injury underwriting, without medical adjudication.
- Funds — floating-side exposure to elite athletic performance, near-zero beta to financial markets.
Margin, collateral, integrity
- Bilateral CSA, zero threshold, daily mark-to-market; initial margin calibrated to historical index volatility.
- Retirement close-out: legs after a voluntary exit terminate at zero; injury legs run to settlement — that's the insured risk.
- No participant with game influence may hold a short position on any player they can affect; league-office attestation at onboarding and position reporting mirroring existing sports-wagering information-sharing.
Settlement is identical to the retail stack — same index, same no-discretion rules: methodology.